Allison Findlay Key West Realtor | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate logo
Allison Findlay Key West Realtor | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate logo
Allison Findlay Key West Realtor | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate logo
Allison Findlay Key West Realtor | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate logo

Areas We Serve

Explore the communities Allison Findlay serves across the Florida Keys, including Key West, Old Town, Casa Marina, The Meadows, Mid Town, New Town and more. Each area offers its own mix of island lifestyle, waterfront opportunities, and local character in the Lower Keys. Browse the communities below to learn more, or reach out for help finding the right fit.

inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/06/dd2d3c4d82e8ead763351459c74e4fb525e427bc.jpg

Key West

In Key West, Florida, USA, the atmosphere is unmistakable: creative, tropical, and deeply connected to the sea. Best for: Buyers seeking a…
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/03/80408d97ffdfe89249111ec830065261e0c3ef0e.webp

Old Town

Old Town is what most people picture when they think of Key West—historic homes, walkability, and close proximity to Duval Street. It’s one of…
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/05/95b06e00c13bb81d26d8e9f8f33c4d42b0530b49.jpg

Midtown

Midtown Key West is a residential neighborhood divided into East and West sections, known for larger lots and classic mid-century homes.
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/03/14de53503bc24c99a57d4a7713e07ac1fb0e01e4.jpg

The Meadows

The Meadows is a quieter pocket just outside Old Town with a mix of historic homes and updated properties. It’s a great option if you want to be…
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/05/c148a40fc450eec4ed3c9d327003909e48f737ca.jpg

Casa Marina

Casa Marina has a quieter, more residential feel with larger lots and close access to the beach. It’s consistently one of the strongest areas for…
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/03/358b1e9cf6a87c5f8208795a0f34aaa953f157b7.webp

Stock Island

Stock Island has evolved quite a bit, offering a mix of working waterfront, newer developments, and marina access. It’s one of the more interesting…
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/06/5ee8a9968c4d87277f469116dd0502d7ebe9b9d7.jpg

Bahama Village

Bahama Village is one of Key West’s most historic and colorful neighborhoods, known for its island charm, walkable streets, and close-knit…
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/06/a4f4e5ee6b86fd2a310e10470fae9ece541cd706.jpg

Historic Seaport

The Historic Seaport area of Key West offers a unique blend of waterfront charm, island history, and vibrant local culture.
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/06/a94d6d28251e995b996b470208483b30b1451c3e.jpg

Key Haven

Key Haven is a highly desirable waterfront community located just minutes from Key West's attractions and Key West International Airport.
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/06/fa565931d40e021a96bd7fb62efba4129ffe08b0.jpg

Lower Keys

The Lower Keys encompass a collection of scenic islands stretching from Big Pine Key to Stock Island, offering a peaceful alternative to the bustle…
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/05/a63cf4feddb1e32a6118f3bf99c0bc49c40fab19.jpg

New Town

New Town Key West offers a mix of older and newer homes in a relaxed residential setting away from the crowds of Old Town.
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/06/98a4608d8c910a6bf0300e2a12df8d989071f45a.jpg

Sunset Key

Sunset Key is an exclusive private island just off the coast of Key West, known for its luxury homes, breathtaking water views, and peaceful…
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/05/c6cd62ec07f5580801343e6b3378a527b9c8de8b.jpg

Truman Annex

Truman Annex is a historic gated community in Key West, offering a peaceful setting with lush landscaping, tree-lined streets, and a rich connection…
Read More