Allison Findlay Key West Realtor | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate logo
Allison Findlay Key West Realtor | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate logo
Allison Findlay Key West Realtor | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate logo
Allison Findlay Key West Realtor | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate logo
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/05/f7f5d9ebd3ba3b70d436f7257258aae02759e000.jpg

Lower Keys

Lower Keys, Florida Homes for Sale

The Lower Keys encompass a collection of scenic islands stretching from Big Pine Key to Stock Island, offering a peaceful alternative to the bustle of Key West. Known for their natural beauty, waterfront living, and outdoor recreation, these communities feature everything from charming canal-front homes to luxurious oceanfront estates. Residents enjoy a relaxed island atmosphere, excellent boating and fishing, and convenient access to Key West's dining, shopping, and cultural attractions.

Map of the area

Finding the best listings for you, please wait...

$45,000,000
Lower Keys
$45,000,000
17075 Overseas Highway, Sugarloaf Key, FL, 33042
31
31
ACTIVE
MLS# 618945
$12,999,999
Lower Keys
$12,999,999
21540 21470 Overseas Highway, Cudjoe Key, FL, 33042
31
19
ACTIVE
MLS# 610484
$12,999,999
Lower Keys
$12,999,999
21540 21470 Overseas Highway, Cudjoe Key, FL, 33042
31
19
ACTIVE
MLS# 612522
3D Tour
$10,499,000
Lower Keys
Virtual Tour
$10,499,000
1041 E Buttonwood Drive, Sugarloaf Key, FL, 33042
6
8
ACTIVE
MLS# 617664
$6,290,000
Lower Keys
$6,290,000
21470 Overseas Highway, Cudjoe Key, FL, 33042
13
7
ACTIVE
MLS# 618705
3D Tour
$5,200,000
Lower Keys
Virtual Tour
$5,200,000
17013 Coral Drive, Sugarloaf Key, FL, 33042
4
4
ACTIVE
MLS# 618184
$5,200,000
Lower Keys
$5,200,000
24200 Overseas Highway, Summerland Key, FL, 33042
5
6
CONTRACT
MLS# 618350
$3,999,999
Lower Keys
$3,999,999
17229 Oleander Lane, Sugarloaf Key, FL, 33042
5
5
ACTIVE
MLS# 618059
3D Tour
$3,899,000
Lower Keys
Virtual Tour
$3,899,000
17015 W Wahoo Lane, Sugarloaf Key, FL, 33042
3
3
ACTIVE
MLS# 618713
3D Tour
$3,750,000
Lower Keys
Virtual Tour
$3,750,000
17387 E Dolphin Street, Sugarloaf Key, FL, 33042
4
4
ACTIVE
MLS# 619842
3D Tour
$3,695,000
Lower Keys
Virtual Tour
$3,695,000
24348 Caribbean Drive, Summerland Key, FL, 33042
3
3
ACTIVE
MLS# 619204
3D Tour
$3,500,000
Lower Keys
Virtual Tour
$3,500,000
1083 Labat Lane, Cudjoe Key, FL, 33042
3
3
ACTIVE
MLS# 619314

Lower Keys Listings

View All Listings
Enter city, zip, neighborhood, address…
Loading in progress…
No results found
Type in anything you’re looking for
Search
Price
BedsSqftLot SizeBathsPriceYear BuiltCreated AtTotal ImagesDays on the Market
Descending
DescendingAscending
12
122448
Lower Keys
$45,000,000
17075 Overseas Highway, Sugarloaf Key, FL, 33042
31
31
ACTIVE
MLS# 618945
Virtual Tour
Lower Keys
$42,000,000
88041 Old Highway, Plantation Key, FL, 33036
6
9
ACTIVE
MLS# 613646
Newly Listed
Lower Keys
$40,000,000
88835 & 88845 Old Highway, Plantation Key, FL, 33070
8
11
ACTIVE
MLS# 619826
Lower Keys
$36,500,000
69401 Overseas Highway, Long Key, FL, 33001
8
10
ACTIVE
MLS# 618724
Virtual Tour
Lower Keys
$35,000,000
57223 Morton Street, Marathon, FL, 33050
9
10
ACTIVE
MLS# 613902
Newly Listed
Lower Keys
$30,000,000
90400 Overseas Highway, Plantation Key, FL, 33070
4
ACTIVE
MLS# 619784
Virtual Tour
Lower Keys
$29,500,000
79775 Overseas Highway, Upper Matecumbe Key Islamorada, FL, 33036
6
6
ACTIVE
MLS# 618152
Newly Listed
Lower Keys
$29,500,000
57783 Morton Street, Marathon, FL, 33050
10
13
ACTIVE
MLS# 619972
Lower Keys
$27,900,000
97601 Overseas Highway, Key Largo, FL, 33037
ACTIVE
MLS# 615835
Lower Keys
$27,500,000
2405 Coco Plum Drive, Marathon, FL, 33050
9
10
ACTIVE
MLS# 614605
Newly Listed
Lower Keys
$27,000,000
88845 Old Highway, Plantation Key, FL, 33070
5
8
ACTIVE
MLS# 619825
Newly Listed
Virtual Tour
Lower Keys
$26,400,000
89505 Old Highway, Plantation Key, FL, 33070
7
10
ACTIVE
MLS# 620022

No results found

Please remove some of the selected filters.
1 2 3 … 200

Talk Through Your Real Estate Plans?

Reach out to Allison Findlay for buying, selling, or investment guidance, area tours, and local insight from Key West Luxury Group.

Send
Submitting
Message Sent
Thank you for reaching out! We'll be in touch shortly.
Oops! Error occurred.
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/03/87c8b0c1b5af167737c4f225c1da3a536a24773a.webp